The Trump administration has wielded the federal government as a weapon against higher education, freezing billions of dollars in grants, demanding compliance in exchange for funding, restricting international student visas, and launching federal investigations alleging “visa fraud." As a result, the U.S. has seen a steeper deterioration in academic freedom than Hungary, India, and Turkey, according to the 2026 Academic Freedom Index.

A paper published this fall in the journal Energy Research & Social Science argues that decades of fossil fuel and libertarian donor influence in higher education helped pave the way for the political coercion that universities face today. This was a strategy first laid out in a 1971 confidential memo from future Supreme Court Justice Lewis Powell, Jr. to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, in which he urged business leaders to commit funding to correct the “imbalance of many faculties.” The sway donors have in setting academic priorities has only accelerated over the years. 

The rise of secretive donor agreements have allowed fossil fuel networks to shape research agendas, create new faculty positions, and claim board of trustees seats, which have in turn weakened independent and transparent research, the authors write.

 I spoke with one of the paper’s six coauthors, Ryan Wishart, an environmental sociologist who has observed fossil fuel interests encroaching on his own university. In 2014, Creighton University, a private Jesuit school, created the Institute for Economic Inquiry with half its $4.5 million funding from the foundation of petrochemical billionaire Charles Koch and the other half from Gail Werner-Robertson, a member of the Koch network who became a trustee of the school. Despite opposition from Creighton faculty, the Institute has since expanded through funding from the libertarian Menard family. A recording from a closed-door Koch donor summit on “Leveraging Science and the Universities” captured one of the Institute faculty privately describing their role as creating a “funnel” to change the minds of students who think government can be a solution to societal problems.

Wishart and his authors offer some solutions for fighting against corporate influence in higher education. They argue that transparency, oversight, faculty unions, and “mutual defense” collective action agreements across universities can all help to strengthen universities’ autonomy. They also offer one practical step that Democrats can now take action on given their newfound control of Congress: a congressional investigation that sheds new light into private donor agreements. We explored these ideas in the following interview, edited for length and clarity.

Why do you think fossil fuel influence in higher education is a template for the political attacks we’re seeing today?

What the federal government has been doing around science, particularly around climate and energy, and higher education has captured a lot of people's attention. What we wanted to do was put that in the context of a much longer-term process of influence by conservative fossil fuel billionaires and chemical magnates throughout the history of universities in the U.S., particularly since the 1970s. Independent research and teaching by universities were a potential threat to those economic interests to the extent it sheds light on harms of their business practices.

The expansion of the university system after the Second World War was largely financed through public funds, and funding has not kept pace. In particular, public universities are becoming more dependent on private dollars. And so that has increased the leverage of those donors, and administrators have gone along with agreements that give donors direct control over who's going to be hired, what's going to be taught, and the research that's done. 

What kind of role have fossil fuel donor networks played in university interference?

We talk about the various foundations like Olin and Koch that started these investments in the 1970s as part of a response to threats that they perceived to the power of business people in society. Then you start to have state legislatures, saying through legislation, ‘we’re going to set up a free market conservative institute within the university, and we're going to pick who's hired, what's going to be taught.’ That's its own direct assault on faculty governance and academic freedom within universities, since it’s not the experts who are picking what questions to research. 

Now, that's happening at the federal level as well, where you have the federal government using carrots and sticks, such as threats of access to current funds or promises of better funding, in order to reshape curriculum and research.

What lessons from history could be applied here?

Since the post-war period, there were established principles that faculty have called "shared governance." Faculty bodies decide what's going to go into curriculum, what needs to be taught, evidence of science and standards, while boards and administrations handle the management of the finances and other aspects of the university. 

You can go back to 1928 and there was this major scandal: The Federal Trade Commission unveiled the electric utilities' hiring of academics to rewrite textbooks and develop pro-market curricula. And that really scandalized the public when the extent of those efforts became public. 

One of the things we recommend as an intervention in the future is a congressional investigation of similar kinds of influence that we're describing in higher education. While we often know more about Koch network-related funding agreements, in part because there's been a lot of attention and litigation, a lot of other funding sources have not been made public. A congressional investigation would be one way that the content of those [donor] agreements could be brought to light.

What impact have private donor agreements from the likes of the Kochs had on universities?

In general, the threat from donor agreements is that they give external actors direct control over hiring, curricula, and programming. These are powers that are traditionally held by faculty, and so that shifts power away from faculty into the donors and administrators. 

Decades ago, the people leading this effort were explicit that giving universities money and letting the faculty pursue knowledge production and teaching in whatever direction they wish is bad for [businessmen’s] interests. The goal was to make it so that they have control over how that money is spent, and that it is only going to be used in ways that are going to advance their economic and ideological interests.

MIT put [David] Koch permanently on a governance board, so you see this kind of direct quid pro quo involved. The Koch network is the one that's been scrutinized the most, and a larger portion of those agreements have become public over time. And with that transparency, you start to see fewer of these types of explicit quid pro quos put in place. Even when it’s not written into the contract, a lot of times [donations are] renewable on an annual basis, so the center and the faculty have to be showing how they're advancing those donors' goals or the flow of money stops. 

Do universities ever reject these arrangements?

UCLA rejected Olin Foundation funding because they said that the conditions of that funding would have compromised academic freedom, but they're fairly exceptional. That was the only major law school that upheld that standard.

I imagine it is pretty unusual that UCLA publicly disclosed what is usually happening behind closed doors. What are some models for what other schools can do?

The most basic thing is that the public can see the text of these agreements. And then from there, the policy sets standards about what constitutes unacceptable strings in terms of donor influence. There are templates — UnKoch My Campus has one example that people can draw from for a conflict of interest policy. Brown faculty has grappled with these issues and has been working on putting policies in place.

Besides donor agreements, what other types of encroachment are there?

As we note in the paper, the portion of university trustees that come from business and finance has been steadily increasing, and that's not accidental. That's one of the things that the donors have invested in shaping: how to change the governance structure of both private and public universities.

How can faculty and students build better institutional autonomy?

The first two steps would be creating policies that require transparency on donor agreements and having university leadership stop engaging in anticipatory obedience. Particularly in the South, you have university boards who are dissolving their faculty senates [to prevent dissent] without even being required to by law. A lot of the agreements that universities have made with the current [Trump] administration, they made even when the basis of that coercion turned out to be overturned by courts. 

The other is strengthening faculty unions. One of the things that gives tenured faculty the ability to do research that doesn't always align with vested interests are the protections of tenure. But increasingly, more people who do the work of universities are no longer tenure track, and that's part of a move towards contingent faculty in higher ed. Unions are a way to counteract that through collective bargaining agreements that can empower faculty and help them actually make sure that policies are enforced. 

Universities are going to need to work together. We point to the mutual defense compact that the Big 10 faculty voted for. Any one university singled out trying to stand up to potentially illegal interference by federal authorities is going to use a lot of resources, so collective solidarity is going to be important.

How is the situation different in public universities, compared to private? 

Private universities have been a target because the prestige that's associated with them is part of what the donors want.

But the direct attacks by the state are actually much more significant than the slow undermining of the foundations that are occurring through private donations. You’re seeing state legislatures directly banning the discussion and teaching of certain concepts in sociology. Florida removed sociology from the core curriculum entirely in addition to restrictions on teaching climate change. 

Florida [state officials] determined that every single sociology intro textbook in print was in violation of state law, and so they ended up requiring all the faculty in the college system to use an open source version that they had cut 60 percent of the content from. 

Part of how I got interested in this was in 2014, the year I started at Creighton University, which is a private Jesuit school, there was something of a controversy, to say the least, because it was announced that they were setting up a Koch-funded center in the business school. That influence has continued to grow and expand over in the business school here at Creighton.

The contradiction with Catholic social teaching has been part of the controversy as much as faculty governance and integrity. For example, we are signed onto the Laudato Si Action Platform that has “ecological economics” as a core goal but no faculty who primarily specialize in it, nor courses focused on it, and no efforts to expand there. Yet we have continued to fundraise for expanding programming in libertarian economics, which are directly criticized by a U.S. Cardinal as anti-ecological.  

It is indicative of the way resource allocation toward teaching and scholarship can be determined not so much by fundraising for the stated mission, but by the ideological preferences of board members who control the purse strings. Our boards are also self-selecting of their replacements, so quite different from political appointment or election for public university systems.

We're small, but a microcosm of some dynamics. [A professor] recently led an effort at Creighton to create a faculty oversight role for donor strings in relation to mission, but it failed to get out of committee in faculty council. 

What new questions and next steps did this research raise for you and your coauthors?

If we can get access to the financial and contractual records that have been private, then that's going to allow more systematic social science research to quantify how this is affecting the direction of research. Nobody has really done large-scale analysis as of yet. 

We know about corporate-funded science, manufacturing uncertainty to delay regulation from tobacco, and other examples from the past, and there's been a fair amount done on climate at this point as well. There could be more systematic research on this, but that's one of the reasons that a congressional investigation would facilitate researchers to start figuring out through comparative analysis which policies are potentially more effective at limiting this kind of donor control.

Do unionization, mutual defense compacts, and cross-institutional alliances really help faculty defend and expand shared governance? Well, that's something that social science has the tools to try and test.

This story has been updated.