As soon as Thursday, the Senate could pass a permitting bill that would speed infrastructure buildouts of all kinds by rewriting the nation’s bedrock environmental laws. While everyone scrambles to make sense of the 494-page bill on an expedited timeline, legal experts are raising the alarm about one overlooked provision: a section that would prevent courts from halting projects whose potential harms haven’t been properly assessed.

Section 1110 of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act would quietly disarm an environmental law that forces federal agencies to evaluate the potential consequences of a project before its buildout. For more than half a century since the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) was enacted, federal agencies have been required to inform the public about a development’s environmental, social, and public health impacts before allowing projects to proceed. If those agencies failed to conduct a sufficient review, communities, advocates, tribes, and local governments could take them to court. 

But under the new bill, courts would be unable to stop construction or a permit even if they found a project was in violation of NEPA. Democratic Senator Jeff Merkley of Oregon was incredulous about the provision on the Senate floor this week: "Are you kidding me? A court finds that the law has been violated but can't issue an injunction under this bill? Therefore the court's irrelevant and the violation of the law continues,” he said. “How is that consistent with a nation of laws?" 

Legal experts say it’s not — that the change would erase accountability from the process and “clos[e] the courthouse doors” to communities while allowing corporations to plow ahead with their plans. The implications are deep and wide for communities in the path of fossil fuel pipelines and power plants, transmission lines, clean energy projects, and data centers. It even has implications for greenlighting non-energy projects, such as U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention facilities. 

How BAAJA would undermine court action

Section 1110 of the bill effectively renders courts toothless even if they did find a federal agency failed to properly assess a project. The court could only direct that agency to correct its paperwork — all while construction, and potentially irreversible damage, is allowed to continue. “It’s a right without a remedy,” said David Cassuto, an environmental law professor at the Elisabeth Haub School of Law at Pace University. 

Cassuto and Andrew Mergen, an environmental law professor at Harvard Law School and former attorney at the U.S. Department of Justice Environment and Natural Resources Division, were two of 75 legal scholars across the country to urge Senate Democrats to scrap the judicial review changes to NEPA, among other changes, that would inflict “permanent, sweeping damage on the nation's core environmental laws.” In an interview, Mergen explained that NEPA has helped ensure public input and prevented “some really bad projects from going forward.” 

But “if there’s no consequence for doing a bad job, we tend to fall into a pattern of cutting corners,” he said.

Aside from reversing the ability of courts to issue injunctions or cancel permits if NEPA is violated, the provision would reduce the window of time parties have to file a lawsuit from 6 years to 150 days after which a project authorization was made public. Critics of the bill say 150 days is too short for communities who may not have immediate access to information or knowledge about a project’s consequences. That restriction would also apply to lawsuits filed under other environmental laws, including the Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and National Historic Preservation Act.

The section would also require a higher bar for plaintiffs to show “direct harm” while giving “substantial deference to the agency” over the scope of its environmental assessment, fundamentally skewing the balance in favor of projects moving forward. And it would fast-track claims to a federal appeals court, bypassing trial courts where evidence — including any backroom deals with industry — is typically brought to light.

The bill comes while fossil fuel companies are seeking to rapidly build out more gas power plants and pipelines for data centers, liquefied natural gas facilities, carbon capture pipelines and facilities, petrochemical plants and facilities for plastic. Pollution limits and safety rules, along with opportunities for public input on development, are already being curtailed under President Trump. 

Even after being substantially weakened by Congress and a Supreme Court ruling in recent years, the NEPA process has been a way for the public to get information about a project before construction proceeds. Reviews prepared under NEPA can be used to enforce other environmental laws like the Clean Water Act and Endangered Species Act, and can trigger tribal consultation requirements under the National Historic Preservation Act if they are found to impact cultural or sacred sites.

Without accountability from the courts, “it becomes much less likely that the government will meaningfully involve the public in other substantive permitting processes and provide the information the public needs to ensure that they're done according to the law,” said Chris Winter, executive director of the Getches-Wilkinson Center for Natural Resources, Energy, and the Environment at the University of Colorado Law School.

NEPA has been used to challenge pipelines and ICE detention centers 

Lawsuits under NEPA are already declining and courts rarely set approvals aside, according to a recent analysis of NEPA challenges from the University of Texas at Austin School of Law, despite industry’s concerns about litigation delaying projects. While limited resources and institutional barriers for plaintiffs have strictly limited the number of such suits, they provide “important constraints” on agencies when the ideologies of a presidential administration are in conflict with environmental law, the same author found previously. 

But community activists do see lawsuits as a critical tool. “NEPA is a lifeline for communities,” said Natali Segovia, a Quechua human rights attorney and executive director of the Indigenous-led legal organization Water Protector Legal Collective. “When a frontline community is impacted by any type of development, there are judicial remedies available. Tying the hands of the courts really threatens shifting the balance of power that we have a society aimed to protect.” 

One famous example is the Keystone XL pipeline, which faced NEPA challenges from environmental and Indigenous advocacy groups and Native American tribes. A court injunction halted the project for nearly seven months while the State Department completed a supplemental environmental review, before President Biden ultimately stopped the project from moving forward. The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe also successfully filed a NEPA lawsuit requiring environmental reviews for the Dakota Access Pipeline, although the pipeline continued operating illegally without a permit for years. 

Other gas pipelines, like the Atlantic Coast Pipeline, have had permits revoked after NEPA challenges by advocacy groups. Under the permitting bill, agency actions over interstate gas pipelines will no longer be considered “major federal actions,” making it even more difficult to require an Environmental Impact Statement.

The statute has been used to force climate and environmental reviews for liquefied natural gas infrastructure, drilling on federal lands, offshore drilling in the Arctic, and data centers. It has even been used by state and local governments and conservation groups to challenge ICE detention centers, including the infamous ‘Alligator Alcatraz’, which has since ceased operations. In April, a Maryland judge halted the construction of another detention center because of its violations of NEPA review.

The changes to NEPA would become even more significant because of another provision in the bill, which makes it extremely difficult for a future administration to revoke federal permits put in place now. 

A gas flare is seen at an oil well site outside Williston, North Dakota. (Photo by Andrew Burton/Getty Images)

BAAJA helps fulfill the oil and gas industry’s wishlist

The American Petroleum Institute, the country’s largest oil and gas lobby group, made permitting reform a top priority this year, along with efforts to secure complete legal immunity from climate lawsuits. Congressional testimony and policy documents show API pushing for the exact judicial reforms that wound up in the bill.

Reporting from Inside Climate News found a senior aide to one Senator was on staff at gas pipeline company Williams while helping advance the bill, which would benefit him and the company. That Senator, Republican Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma, who recently retired from his position as CEO of Williams before hiring his aide, introduced a bill limiting the ability of states and tribes to challenge pipelines — similar to provisions that were ultimately included in BAAJA.

According to the University of Texas at Austin Law’s analysis, the bill’s limits on court remedies would disproportionately benefit fossil fuel projects on federal land.

The bill will move to the House next, where it could still face roadblocks, if it passes the Senate without amendments. Former Obama EPA chief and Biden advisor Gina McCarthy put it succinctly: "If a bill has the full backing of President Trump and this White House, then that should give everyone pause.”